Child Death Reviews
This resource outlines the framework set out in the Child Death Review: Statutory and Operational Guidance in England and the statutory guidance in Working Together to Safeguard Children.
The guidance sets out the key features of what a good child death review process should look like in order to standardise practice nationally and enable thematic learning to prevent future deaths.
Note: The Child Death Review Statutory Guidance should be seen as complementary to the SUDI/C Guidelines and providing clarity when processes overlap.
The child death review partners will establish a structure and process (for their agreed area) to carry out this duty and publicise those arrangements.This is a LIVE online resource; updated by tri.x as and when it needs to be in response to changes in legislation and national guidance.
When a child dies, in any circumstances, it is important for parents and families to understand what has happened. Families experiencing such a tragedy should be met with empathy and compassion. They need clear and sensitive communication. They also need to understand what happened to their child and know that people will learn from what happened. The process of expertly reviewing all children's deaths is grounded in deep respect for the rights of children and their families, with the intention of preventing future child deaths.
The Child Death Review: Statutory and Operational Guidance (England) says that a child death review should be carried out for all children under 18 years of age regardless of the cause of death. This includes the death of any live-born baby where a death certificate has been issued. In the event that the birth is not attended by a healthcare professional, child death review partners may carry out initial enquiries to determine whether or not the baby was born alive. If these enquiries determine that the baby was born alive the death must be reviewed.
For the avoidance of doubt, it does not include stillbirths, late foetal loss, or terminations of pregnancy (of any gestation) carried out within the law.
- Stillbirth: baby born without signs of life after 24 weeks gestation;
- Late foetal loss: where a pregnancy ends without signs of life before 24 weeks gestation.
Cases where there is a live birth after a planned termination of pregnancy carried out within the law are not subject to a child death review.
3. Statutory Requirements for Child Death Reviews
The responsibility for ensuring child death reviews are carried out is held by 'child death review partners,' who, in relation to a local authority area in England, are defined as the local authority for that area and any clinical commissioning groups operating in the local authority area.
Child death review partners must make arrangements to review all deaths of children normally resident in the local area and, if they consider it appropriate, for any non-resident child who has died in their area.
Child death review partners for two or more local authority areas may combine and agree that their areas be treated as a single area for the purpose of undertaking child death reviews.
Child death review partners must make arrangements for the analysis of information from all deaths reviewed. They should ensure that a designated doctor for child deaths is appointed to any multi-agency panel (or structure in place to review deaths). The designated doctor for child deaths should be a senior paediatrician who can take a lead role in the review process. Child death review partners should ensure a process is in place whereby the designated doctor for child deaths is notified of each child death and is sent relevant information.
The child death review partners should consider the core representation of any panel or structure they set up to conduct reviews and this would ideally include: public health; the designated doctor for child deaths for the local area; social services; police; the designated doctor or nurse for safeguarding; primary care (GP or health visitor); nursing and/or midwifery; lay representation; and other professionals that child death review partners consider should be involved. It is for child death review partners to determine what representation they have in any structure reviewing child deaths.
The purpose of a review and/or analysis is to identify any matters relating to the death, or deaths, that are relevant to the welfare of children in the area or to public health and safety, and to consider whether action should be taken in relation to any matters identified. If child death review partners find action should be taken by a person or organisation, they must inform them. In addition, child death review partners:
- Must, at such times as they consider appropriate, prepare and publish reports on:
- What they have done as a result of the child death review arrangements in their area; and
- How effective the arrangements have been in practice.
- May request information from a person or organisation for the purposes of enabling or assisting the review and/or analysis process - the person or organisation must comply with the request, and if they do not, the child death review partners may take legal action to seek enforcement;
- May make payments directly towards expenditure incurred in connection with arrangements made for child death reviews or analysis of information about deaths reviewed, or by contributing to a fund out of which payments may be made; and may provide staff, goods, services, accommodation or other resources to any person for purposes connected with the child death review or analysis process.
Whilst Child Death Review partners are free to establish their own structure and process to review the deaths of children normally resident in their geographical area of responsibility based on local need, they should ensure that the processes align to the general principles set out in the national guidance in order to enable local lessons to be reflected on at a national level. In the Child Death Review: Statutory and Operational Guidance (England), the body conducting the Child Death Review reviews is identified as a Child Death Overview Panel.
The Child Death Review partners should publicise information on the arrangements for child death reviews in their area. This should include who the accountable officials are (the local authority chief executive and the accountable officer of the clinical commissioning group), which local authority and clinical commissioning group partners are involved, what geographical area is covered and who the designated doctor for child deaths is.
The collation and sharing of the learning from reviews will be managed by the National Child Mortality Database through the use of standardised forms.
4. Child Death Review: Statutory and Operational Guidance
Sets out the detailed process to follow including the following areas:
Immediate decision making and notifications - This relates to the immediate actions to be taken after the death of a child, such as notification of death, or deciding whether other investigations are warranted. This includes determining whether the death meets the criteria for a Joint Agency Response.
A Joint Agency Response should be triggered if a child's death:
- Is or could be due to external causes;
- Is sudden and there is no immediately apparent cause (incl. SUDI/C);
- Occurs in custody, or where the child was detained under the Mental Health Act;
- Where the initial circumstances raise any suspicions that the death may not have been natural; or
- In the case of a stillbirth where no healthcare professional was in attendance.
In practice, the majority of such discussions will happen in a clinical setting, but may require input from other agencies in certain cases.
Criteria for referral of deaths to coroner - covers the reasons for referral to the coroner.
Investigating and information gathering - This is predominantly for those involved in the preliminary stages of the child death review process in the aftermath of a child's death. It also summarises other investigations that may run in parallel to the child death review process.
The Child Death Review Meeting - This relates to the discussion of the death of a child by the professionals who were directly involved in the care of that child during their life and those professionals who were involved in the investigation into their death. The outputs of this meeting will inform the statutory independent multi-agency panel arranged by child death review partners at the Child Death Overview Panel (CDOP) or equivalent.
Review of child deaths at a Child Death Overview Panel (CDOP) - This describes some of the statutory requirements placed upon child death review (CDR) partners, and the functions that they are expected to carry out. It outlines the function of an independent and multi-agency panel that should be established to scrutinise all aspects of a child's death, using evidence generated in the steps which precede this stage of the overall child death review process. This is known as a Child Death Overview Panel (CDOP) or equivalent.
Roles and responsibilities of CDOP members - sets out the roles and responsibilities of the different agencies on the panel.
Specific situations - additional guidance covering the areas set out below
Suggested membership for themed panels - Examples which areas may wish to consider for themed CDOP panels.
Family Engagement and Bereavement Support - Supporting and engaging the family who have lost a child is of prime importance throughout the entire child death review process. Recognising the complexity of the process, and the different emotional responses that bereavement can bring, families should be given a single, named point of contact, i.e. the "key worker", for information on the processes following their child's death, and who can signpost them to sources of support.
The key worker for bereaved families responsibilities and competencies - all bereaved families should be given a single, named point of contact, who can provide information on the child death review process, and who can signpost them to sources of support.
Child Death Review Terminology - sets out the definitions used in the guidance.
The death of a child is a devastating loss that profoundly affects bereaved parents as well as siblings, grandparents, extended family, friends and professionals who were involved in caring for the child in any capacity. The Child Death Review process aims to balance improving the experience of bereaved families, and professionals involved in caring for children at a traumatic time with ensuring that information is systematically captured in every case to enable learning from those events to prevent future deaths.
5. Bereavement Support
'When a child dies: a guide for parents and carers' (NHS England) - sets out the steps that follow the death of a child.
See also: Family Engagement and Bereavement Support.
National Bereavement charities that offer helplines, e-mail support, and online communities and message boards for families when a baby or child has died include:
See also: Child Death Review Statutory and Operational Guidance (England), Appendix 7: Bereavement resources - organisations which offer bereavement support for families services.
Local areas may well have services that can offer bereavement support more locally.
6. Related Guidance
Child Death Review: Statutory and Operational Guidance (England) - Statutory and operational guidance for clinical commissioning groups and local authorities as child death review partners, which sets out the full process that follows the death of a child who is normally resident in England.
Sudden unexpected death in infancy and childhood - multi-agency guidelines for care and investigation - Royal College of Pathologists (RCPath)
Child Death Reviews Legislation - Sections 16M-Q of the Children Act 2004